Senator Pat Toomey Wants SEC to Provide Clarity As to Which Crypto They View as Security

Senator Pat Toomey Wants SEC to Provide Clarity As to Which Crypto They View as Security

In a recent Squawk Box show episode, Senator Pat Toomey has called crypto “a really important and innovative new category of finance” and urged the SEC to explain what criteria they use to apply the securities law to cryptocurrencies, so that certain regulatory laws can be created.

"I'm not in the camp that thinks that there should never be any kind of regulation over any kind of #cryptocurrency ... but I do think there needs to be transparency and objectivity about what we're doing here," says @SenToomey on regulating #crypto #bitcoin— Squawk Box (@SquawkCNBC) September 15, 2021

The SEC only have power over securities but apply it to crypto: Senator Toomey

US Senator for Pennsylvania, Pat Toomey, has spoken during the CNBC’s Squawk Box about the regulatory issues that are currently seen in the crypto industry, or rather, lack of regulatory clarity – an issue that multiple players in the crypto industry have recently complained about, including Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong.

Toomey mentioned his exchange of opinions he had with the SEC chairman Gary Gensler on Tuesday, where he stated that the SEC has not laid out any clear guidelines as to what cryptocurrencies they believe to be securities. The agency’s regulatory regime is limited to securities and platforms that trade them, reminded the senator to the CNBC audience. If certain cryptos are not securities, then the senator pointed out, the SEC does not have powers to regulate them.

BTC and ETH are not securities but stablecoins are, Gensler says

The senator stated that Bitcoin and Ethereum are definitely not securities but look more like commodities and Toomey said that Gensler agrees to that. However, according to Toomey, Gary Gensler views stablecoins as securities but the senator himself believes they are not.

According to Toomey, stablecoins do not meet the legal test for what a security is.

Toomey, Perianne Boring ask SEC to provide clarity here

Pat Toomey stated that he would very much like the regulatory securities and exchange agency to clarify what criteria and characteristics they use to announce a cryptocurrency a security. When this happens, the government will be able to enforce the laws to regulate cryptocurrencies.

Toomey assured that he is not calling against crypto regulation, however, he does what transparency and objectivity about the regulation of the crypto industry. So far, he says, the SEC is taking enforcement actions regarding crypto companies without having laid out how they use the current securities law to regulate cryptocurrencies.

The SEC has been in a legal war with Ripple Labs since December 2020, claiming that XRP is an unregistered security. In late 2020, it sued Ripple Labs, CEO Brad Garlinghouse and co-founder Chris Larsen for trading this asset.

Recently, the agency also threatened to sue Coinbase for their intention to launch a lending service to let their customers earn yields on their crypto.

Perianne Boring, founder and president of the Chamber of Digital Commerce, made a similar statement earlier today on CNBC – she said that the industry needs clear and transparent regulation, rules that crypto companies would be able to comply with the regulators by.

"We need clear and predictable guidance. Chair Gensler has stated multiple times that he believes the law is clear. That is not true," says @DigitalChamber's @PerianneDC. "I have yet to have one company say 'Yeah, we understand what the rules to the road are.'"— Squawk Box (@SquawkCNBC) September 15, 2021